Geeks, Girls, and Secret Identities
Hardcover, 307 pages
Published October 1st 2012 by Arthur A. Levine Books/Scholastic, Inc. (first published September 1st 2012)
ISBN 0545335485 (ISBN13: 9780545335485)
(I managed to snag a paperback copy from a Scholastic order!)
This time, when Kathy (aka @TheBrainLair) and I announced our book selection, another buddy decided to join in the fun. So help us welcome Sherry (aka @LibraryFanatic) to the Batty fold. I haven't met her in real life, but I can assure you that she's just as Batty as we are!
As is tradition, we have a "Batty About Books" image. Kathy put three bats on this one, instead of our usual shoes because Sherry doesn't have the Batgirl shoes!
My thoughts reside here, in purple. Any of Kathy's responses are in blue, and Sherry chose green. Check out the rest of the discussion by visiting The Brain Lair for Kathy's thoughts with our responses and Library Fanatic for Sherry's.
We decided to start our discussion of each book by giving our thoughts about cover appeal.
Maria says: It’s big, bold, and over the top silly. I like that about it. I also think it’s clear from the cover that it’s a departure from what we’ve been reading lately. I love all the circuitry on the enormous robot, and the evil glint in its eyes. The matching “S”s on the shirts of the boys makes it feel like they are part of some kind of super powered club. (Confirmed by the copy on the back, of course). I also like how the three boys have different sizes and shapes. How often do we see that when there are girls on a cover? I have to admit, I’m looking forward to a funny story. Yet I’m always slightly cautious about mocking and/or stereotypes when it comes to two major categories - girls and geeks. Can Mike Jung give us a funny tale without resorting to this? I’ve heard great things about the book, so I’m ready to dive in.
Kathy: I’m with you Maria! I want to see girls and geeks lifted up and out of the stereotypes! I want a fun read without them being made fun of! I have only read the first line of the inside jacket and nothing else so I had no idea what the book was going to be about! I saw the cover (got an ARC from Scholastic) and immediately brought it home!! I bought the hardcover because I really wanted to see the final art!
Part One Reactions
I was jazzed to start this book. While the superhero/ fantasy theme is something I read frequently, I was definitely in the mood for a comedy. I’ve been reading a ton of books from a girl’s perspective (and it’s awesome that I can find enough books to do that!), but I like to mix it up with books from a boy’s POV too. The fact that it made the list of Charlotte’s Library blog post Looking for Kids of Color in MG Sci-Fi/Fantasy books made me even happier.
I’m going to be honest here, I was REALLY concerned after the first few pages. The opening was funny, but I had a hard time getting past the fan club of “girls who probably spend all their time trying on each other’s clothes”. (pg 1) I spend a lot of my Twitter and other online time interacting with women who are fans of things like comics and science fiction who are VERY sensitive about this kind of thing. On page 4 we get another of the trio claiming that a GIRL couldn’t really be a Captain Stupendous fan. *sighs*
So I took a deep breath and reminded myself that the characters who are speaking are middle school boys. While I hope and pray that things will get better, middle school is a time when stereotypes rule. I decided to continue with the attitude that this would be a lesson they could learn during the story. I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who felt this way. I’m determined to wait it out and kept reminding myself this was only the beginning, but I was disturbed by the girls like clothes and pretty things attitude.
Armed with my slightly calmer mindset, I read on.
The illustrations in this book are making me very happy. Something struck me as feeling really familiar about them. The faces remind me of the Batman Beyond animated series. Once I actually took the time to look at this illustrator’s name, I knew. This guy rocks. He does some Batgirl and Supergirl short comics, and he has a series called Cleopatra in Space (webcomic, though he has some compilations for sale that I’ve always meant to check out.)
The humor level is very entertaining. It is a bit of an odd feeling trying to have this type of book chat about a funny book. The ones we’ve done before have been deep and rich (or not), but humor wasn’t their primary objective. I love the snarky dialogue between the characters. I love the fact that I feel like I’m in a comic book - but I’m following the common masses instead of the characters with the powers. (Though I did LOVE The Cloak Society). I’ve gotten so many chuckles out of this first third of the book that I’m sure my students will adore it. I can see it being a fast read. One you sit down and laugh through but with some “seriousness” thrown in. Jung has brought up Max’s and George’s home life several times and I wonder if this will serve to “ground” the novel. I do LOVE the humor in this and it’s very welcomed after so many serious reads! I do love the humor and the illustrations so far!
Now that we’ve gotten to the part that gives us a lot more on Polly, I’m feeling much happier. The fact that she [SPOILER REMOVED] cracks me up. The best part, in my mind, is the fact that it isn’t this event that makes her a kick butt lady. No, she had already taken karate for six years before, and she could take on any of the three boys easily. Polly’s role in the story has definitely brought me around on the “girls” part of the tale. (Can we say that part about Polly? I know it’s on the Scholastic website but it’s not listed on the jacket cover anywhere. Is it on the Scholastic version?) I mention Polly on my side too! She is super awesome! I can’t wait to learn more about her! (Oooo... good point. For those of you reading this as a post, know that I edited out a spoiler, something way cool about Polly!)
This has been a fun read so far, and I’m looking forward to reading the rest and getting this book into the hands of my students.
Kathy, Sherry and I had some discussion over the aspect of the plot that was “Spoilery”. Kathy did some poking around, and discovered that the plot point is mentioned a lot - many different places that readers would go to learn more about the book and decide if they wanted to read it. So - what exactly IS a spoiler? And does hearing one ruin your enjoyment of a story? Does it matter what kind of spoiler it is? This sounds like a great topic for a separate discussion! In the meantime, check out the link below for information from a study about how spoilers impact your enjoyment of a story. (This study claims that they don’t “ruin” it!) What do you think?